OT - Recommendations for restaurants on Oahu, HI

Apr 10, 2006 8 Replies
Jump to replies (8)

OK, only slightly OT, as I'm also asking for wine list recs. as well.



We will be in Hawai'i for much of September. I've already made dining reservations for our time on Kaua'i, and then most of the time on the North Shore of Oahu. I'm looking for recommendations for fine-dining restaurants, especially with great wine lists. Right now, we are already doing La Mer (a favorite of ours), Bali by the Sea (have had good, and not so good experiences here), 3660 On the Rise (always good), Alan Wong's King St (should be re-opened by then), and would like to add two more. In years past, we've done the Hau Tree Lanai, Aaron's On Top of the Ala Moana, John Domminis', Michel's at the Colony Surf, Sam Choy's and Nick's Fishouse. Of these, I rate Aaron's #1, Domminis' & Hau Tree tied for #2, with Michel's and Nick's at the bottom of the list. While I can throw two of these into the mix, I'd rather try someplace new.



Are there any new spots, that I should look into? Who is the " hottest" new chef on Oahu?



Also, I've heard some good recommendations for Ola [SP?] on the North Shore. Any reports, as we have one night without dining reservations there?



While I'm not looking to spend ALL of the money that I can, I don't hesitate to dine anyplace so long as there is good value.



Thank you for your thoughts, Hunt


If Roy's is still there -- and still good -- it is worth a trip to Hawai'i Kai. Also, there used to be a small Italian restaurant called Baci Due in Kaimuki. I can't vouch for the wine list at either place, since I was too poor to drink wine in restaurants when I lived there.

I believe that the Roy's (original, I think) is still open in Hawai'i Kai. Of the various ones that I have tried, I rate it the lowest. His wine list is OK, but not that interesting.

I have never heard of Baci Due. I will check it out and see what's happening there.

I got a strong rec. from Chef Mavro's. He was exec. chef at La Mer and now has an eponymous restaurant just up from Waikiki.

Thanks for the suggestions, Hunt

Hi,

This question is right up my alley. My wife and I live on Oahu, and frequently go to all fine-dining restaurants often.

Without a doubt, Chef Mavro (as someone mentioned) is the only wine and food matching restaurant. He is from south France and worked at the halekulani, and the Four Seasons Maui. The menu is friend with a Hawaiian flare. He uses local farmed produce and matches it with wine. The food is fantastic. The restaurant has a website and it list the menu. He changes the menu every season. The wine list small--he only carries the wines for his matching food courses.

As for Roys, the food is good, but I don't like the fact there are so many Roy's. The restaurant in Hawaii Kai is loud and busy. I don't think you can keep quality high when there are so many restaurants..

One of my new favorites is Hiroshis located at Restaurant Row. The menu is Eurasian cosine in a tapas format. The food is great. I try to eat there every 2 weeks or so. The Ahi two ways is fantastic. The wine list is prepared by one of only two Master Sommeliers in Hawaii.

If you are looking for Italian food, I would try Sarentos at the top of the Ilakai. The view is spectacular and the food is good. The wine cellar is the largest in the state. It is probably the only restaurant in Honolulu that actually makes its own pasta.

If you don't mind a drive, the restaurant Azuls at the Ihlani Resort on the west side serves great food. The restaurant serves Mediterranean cuisine with a Hawaiian Flare. I especially enjoyed the Osso Busco. The wine list is extensive.

I hope this of assistance. If you need more information, like where to get good wine, etc Just let me know. All the restaurants charge a corking fee if you would like to bring your own wine.

Chris

Chris,

Thanks for the comments on Chef Mavro's. I think that this will be a "given," now. There have been a few disparaging comments on the Chowhound site, regarding this restaurant, but more glowing reports have overcome any hesitation that I may have had. Besides, his restaurant is just up McCully St from where we are staying.

Many years ago, we did what is now Sarento's (cannot recall the name), and it was then just OK. I've also heard many good reviews of this restaurant.

I believe that I have filled the nights for this trip completely, plus have also got most "lunches" filled, as well.

I'll do some reviews of the trip on Chowhound, and any wine critiques here.

I agree about Roy's. While I like the food, and have dined at most on US soil, they are rather like Morton's, except that the exec. chef has more latitude. We'll dine at the one in Pouipo, Kaua`i, just because the last time we were there, it had yet to re-open after Iniki. Of all of the Roy's, I found the one at Hawai`i Kai to be the farthest down the dining scale, followed closely by one of the two on Maui (they are actually next door to each other). There was a young lady (oh, I wish I could recall her name), who was exec. chef at Waikoloa, who added a Southwest infulence to the Roy's dishes. She was tops, in my book, but as of last year is no longer with the group. The "kids" working at Wiakoloa did not even recall her, when I tried to find out her name.

As for corkage, I usually don't travel with my wine, and will only bring a very special bottle to a local restaurant, when there is a real need to do so. We usually pick up a few bottles of white, and red locally, and have them in our room, but I just bite the bullet and order off of the wine list when dining away from home. Besides, it often gives me the opportunity to experience wine that I have never heard of, or am likely to have seen. If the sommelier/cellar-master has done a good job, knows their cellar, and the work of the kitchen, some magical pairing can result. Yes, it can be more expensive, but more and more, I find that restauranteurs are working hard to make the wine experience better for their patrons. Fairly pricing the wine, yields many more sales, and a great pairing can really enhance the experience.

Reports to follow - say mid-October, as we head to London, immediately after Hawai`i.

Thanks for the responses. Hunt

Well, I am out of touch on htis subject. Last I knew there was one Roy's, maybe two. Baci Due may have gone the way of most restaurants.

Andy

I haven't checked their Web site, but I only know of the Hawai`i Kai Roy's ( original?) on Oahu. As with most chains, Roy's can be a bit corporate, though Roy Yamaguchi does allow his exec. chefs a bit of leeway. The Waikoloa Roy's featured a young chef with a distinct Southwest bent. Her take on Yamaguchi's fare was very, very good. Unfortunately, she's no longer there, and the kids working the room and kitchen didn't even remember her. Dang, I wish I'd written down her name, as she'd be one to follow.

I'll do the Roy's on Kaua`i, as it wasn't open, after Iniki, last trip, and I want to give all of the island restaurants a chance.

I've seen nothing on Baci Due - Honolulu?

Hunt

The Bistro in Century Center

3660 on the Rise

two excellent restaurants

According to my Google search, Baci Due is now Baci Bistro and has moved to Kailua (the one on O'ahu). The online wine list looks meager.

Enjoy! Wherever you go. And don't forget to report back.

Andy

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required