Our Bordeaux group veered to Napa for a Phelps dinner, we gathered at Balvanera for bacalao croquettes,cauliflower arancini, octopus, provoleta, beef empanadas, blood sausage, skirt steak, and fries.
NV Marteaux Guillaume Essential Champagne New producer to me, and I quite liked. Fresh, peachy, hint of almond and pastry dough. B+
2010 Marguet Ambonnay Champagne (dg 2017) Toasty, touch of vanilla, bright, long. B+/A-This was originally a general Phelps dinner, but those with Backus had to back out, so ended up all Insignia (one auction)
1976 Phelps Insignia Lovely and long, elegant cassis fruit accented with coffee, leather, and herbs. Supple, balanced. A-1978 Phelps Insignia Black berries and currants, minty herbs, smoke. Good acidic balance, a little smoked meat note with time. A-/B+
1985 Phelps Insignia Auction Reserve Black plums and some cedar, but dominated by eucalyptus. So much we were wondering if this was spiked by Heitz Martha’s. :) But I love Martha’s and loved this wine. Long and strong. A-1992 Phelps Insignia Rich black plum and cassis, some mocha, velvety finish. B+
1994 Phelps Insignia Very ripe, blackberries and blueberries, pushing envelope for me but likable. B1995 Phelps Insignia Showing some heat, cassis fruit with a touch of kirsch, but good finish B-
1996 Phelps Insignia Ripe but balanced,rich cassis and mocha, big and long. B+1997 Phelps Insignia Uberripe, fruit has a bit of a roasted edge, a little volatility, pruney notes on finish, C+
A clear stylistic shift in the 90s, though I still enjoyed some of them. The ‘97 not so much. 🙂 Fun and informatic night.
Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.