TN Joseph Phelps Insignia 1974

Oct 17, 2004 3 Replies

The 1974 Joseph Phelps Insignia is 94% Cabernet Sauvignon and 6% Merlot. Alcohol is listed as 13.8%. It cost US$12.29 when I bought it shortly after release. The fill was still well in the neck and the cork was quite sound.



This wine is the equal of any of the top California wines of this era that I have had, such as Ridge Monte Bello. It is still quite dark scarlet with nearly no indication of age around the rim. Both the bouquet and taste are very intense, very complex, and very well balanced. There now is enough acidity and the medium tannins are now rounded. Words that come to mind include cassis, hint of blackberry, touch of spice, hint of pepper, hint of bell pepper. The finish is quite long. It has the sort of weight and general structure that you might get if you blended a full Ch. Latour with some Petrus, although it is quite different from both of these wines in bouquet and taste. You would have to be very critical to find a fault with this wine. It probably will last well for many more years, but I think it may now be at the peak.



My mailbox is always full to avoid spam. To contact me, erase snipped-for-privacy@webtv.net from my email address. Then add snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com . I do not check this box every day, so post if you need a quick response.



Great notes, CW. Phelps Insignia is one of my favorite Cabernet-based CA wines and I've usually preferred it to Phelps's other cabs (Eisele and Backus) in the years when they were made. It's interesting to note how well it can age, given how attractive a wine it is in its youth.

Mark Lipton

=>8^0 Bite your tongue, Mark! As much as I love the Insignia (and the Backus), the Eisele Vineyard wines I've had from Phelps are what I would consider Napa Valley "First Growths".

Alas, all I have left is a single bottle of the 1991 Phelps Eiselle - but I have very vivid recollection of the 1977 Eisele from a Christmas luncheon about 20 years ago at the now defunct Mauro's in downtown Los Angeles. (That was the elegant restaurant featured in the movie "Pretty Woman".)

The wine was fetched from the cellar and decanted over a candle using a very pretentious looking contraption. It was quite an experience to see, and an absolute *delight* to drink! It cost me all of ~$45US at the time - which I feel was quite reasonable - especially considering that today the wines from that vineyard sell for First Growth Bordeaux prices. :^(

BTW, I'm attending a vertical of 1997-2001 Insignia this weekend. I'll try to post notes, but I'm not nearly as good with the desciptive adjectives as some (many?) of the other a.f.w members. Sorry 'bout that. :^(

Tom S

I understand, Tom, but still stand by my statement. They are stylistically at two ends of the spectrum, and I give the nod to the Insignia because of its balance, finesse and character. To me, Insignia underscores the wisdom of the Bordelais: you can make a wine of unique character by blending different varietals in response to the differing conditions of each vintage. I should also note that I haven't had (or been able to afford) an Eisele for many a year now, so my statement is based on the wines of the '80s primarily.

Just my $0.02, Mark Lipton

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required