TN: Fevre, ESJ, Ecard, Gosset, Gadais, Thivin

Aug 28, 2023 Last reply: 2 years ago 4 Replies

I forgot one wine from park concert



2020 Gadais Peninsula Muscadet Citrus, floral, moderate acids, not sure I’d peg as Muscadet blind. B-

Friday grilled marinated Korean chicken with cold soba and tomato, grilled peppers, and Swiss chard.



2021 Thivin Reverdon Brouilly I’ve been a big 2021 Bojo fan, but this one didn’t really do it for me. A little burnt tire on nose, cranberry and green herbs. B-/C+

Saturday we went up for dinner at friends in Briarcliff, oysters followed by delicious fall off bone lamb shanks in a laksa sauce, and bok choy/Shanghai tips.



NV Gosset Grande Rose I remain a fan. Crunchy red fruits, baking bread, good finish. B+/A-


2014 Fevre Montmains Chablis 1er Lemon, green apple, some citrus blossom, wet rocks. This has that 2014 verve, but it is a little shorter than optimal, other than that classic. B+/B


2005 Edmund St John Wylie -Fenaughty Syrah Mark thought this had a medicinal finish, I got herby, but not medicinal. Black raspberry, black pepper, some oregano, leather. Resolved tannin, good finish. B+



Sunday oysters, grilled arctic char, artichoke/truffle cuscinetti, caprese, corn avocado salad



NV Gosset Grande Reserve (375 ml) I found this a little flat and short, but I often find half bottles of Champagne a bit lacking. I’ve liked more in 750.


2002 Ecard “Narbantons” Sauvigny-les Beaune 1er Man this is in a good place. Resolved tannin, bright but not harsh acids, lacy texture, red currants and pomegranate, smoke. Really nice. A-

My last notes for a bit, having gallbladder out tomorrow.



Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.


Best of luck, DaleW. My brother had that done years ago; hopefully, they can do the operation with only a small incision.

Dan-O

Sorry to hear this. I've got a bottle or two of this in the cellar. Will report back on my experiences (I hope it was a bottle issue)

Good to hear. I finished my last bottle last year IIRC.

Oh, I have fond memories of this wine. Probably been a decade since our last bottle. Glad you hang onto yours long enough for this result.

Best of luck with the surgery, Dale! Mark Lipton

Thanks all, everything went well

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required