Max Hauser was visiting NY, and very generously invited Jason (Jaybert41) and I to join him at a dinner at the James Beard House. It was great meeting Max in person, and we had a VERY good meal. The chefs were David Kinch from Manresa in Los Gatos CA, and Daniel Patterson from Frisson in San Francisco. Wines donated by importers who support the Beard Foundation.
Before we sat down, we enjoyed some wine and hors d'oeuvres in the garden. Waiters passed around: Sweet Corn Croquettes (yummy, explode in mouth). Black Olive Madeleines (nice juxtaposition of sweet and salty). Marinated Scallops with Garden Herbs (very aromatic, kind of ceviche meets tartare, lots of herbs) Red and Yellow Beet Macaroons - more a tease than a food, but fun Foie Gras "Truffles" Wow. Just wow.
The apertif wines were: NV Marques de Monistrol Brut Rosé - I was a little sceptical of a pink cava, but this was actually a nice wine. Just slightly sweeter than what I'd consider a true brut, but with nice strawberry fruit and clean finish.B NV Deutz Brut - lighter styled Champagne, lightly yeasty, tasty. B/B+
We sat, and the courses started coming (alternating chefs):
Corn-and-Tomato Salad with Basil "New Version" (Kinch) Really astounding. A sweet corn puree topped with a mixed tomato salad, a little wafer horn on top. As good a salad as I've ever had.
2001 Langlois Chateau Saumur Vieilles Vignes - is this Chenin? Sauvignon Blanc? Tasted like Chardonnay or Pinot Blanc to me. But a quick check today indicates it must be Chenin. Not much character, a light hint of oak, decent acidity, manages to be pleasantly inoffensive. B-
Artichoke Saffron Soup with Spelt and Spicy Onion Relish (Patterson) The Beard House is an old brownstone, and the dining is split between several rooms. As this was being served in the adjacent room, the aromas penetrated our room. Pretty damn good, though not as exciting as the previous course.
2003 Salviano Orvieto Classico Superiore - served too cold. Jason and I discussed what a tough match this was in any case- soups are always tough, artichokes are always tough, etc. Not the course to splurge on,an Orvieto is about right. Once warmed, a clean competent white, enough acidity, a slight nutty note. B/B- Wild Japanese Sea Bass and Assorted Shellfish in a Delicate Green Curry (Kinch) Great fish, nice sweet bivalve flesh, tasty sauce. Very very good.
Lucien Albrecht Cuvée Cecile Pinot Gris 2001 Fat ripe PG with some residual sugar, bordering on flabby. Someone queries whether there's some possible TCA. Maybe, though it doesn't smell exactly like a corked wine to me. I've had a similar reaction to some late-harvest PG before
-something a bit ..dank, though not actually mildewy. Not sure if this was a good bottle, but if so C+/B- (my neighbor liked more than I).
Poached and Seared Lamb with Eggplant and Fried Chickpeas (Patterson) The chef explained later this was done in a kind of "boil in bag" method. Some Morrocan spices, delicious lamb, nice accompaniment (the frying really brought out the nuttiness of the chickpeas).
2000 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco My favorite of the night. Classic Piemonte tar and leather, moderate tannins, long finish. Very good for a co-op normale, and with a future. A-/B+
Of the savory courses, the tomato corn salad was my favorite, followed by the bass and lamb (tie). The soup was in fourth this night, but could have been a strong first in a good restaurant meal. Great food overall.
I don't normally eat dessert, but took a tiny sample of each offering: Stone Fruit and Jasmine Tea Gelée with Mint (Kinch) Chocolate Cereal (Garrett Melkonian , Pastry Chef, Frisson) Big hits with the table.
The dessert wine was the 1998 Chapoutier Banyuls. Prunes and raisins, with a bit of a licorice note on the end. A B from me (not bad, as Banyuls is not my favorite AC)
Thanks to Max for this great evening. One note- some folks might have noted that there has been some controversary re the Beard Foundation lately. The president has been removed, under a bit of a cloud. One acquaintance told me "I'd boycott the place." I think now, while they are getting their house in order, and are under intense public scrutiny, is the exact time (if you approve of the cause) to support them, in full confidence that everything is being done right.
Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C mediocre. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency Dale
Dale Williams Drop "damnspam" to reply