All of the archived pages are the same - about Chianti Classico and other Chianti.. I'm using Netscape 8.1 Is that all that is archived or do I have a browser conflict??
"John Roenigk" in news:%wMHf.1117$ snipped-for-privacy@newsread2.news.pas.earthlink.net:
John, I won't presume to speak for current newsgroup readers, or even regulars. But for the record, that would be an atypical topic for a longtime newsgroup's FAQ. It surfaced as a subject of chronic argument on newsgroups only some six years ago (late 1999 to early 2000, a period when I was not reading, BTW) and most established newsgroups' FAQs are older than that. "Top posting" is a matter of much personal preference and (in late years) loud opinion, and very little objective information. It is not the longstanding format for newsgroup postings. It can be seen occasionally though from the beginning. Someone who is, say, embedding multiple quotations in a well-crafted response can employ it effectively, among other tools to place emphasis. But that is someone who is using it under control, as a compositional tool. The usual objection came about from people doing it mechanistically because that's how their latter-day news readers were set up (sometimes matching an email convention). For many more years than not, the standard programs that people used to post to newsgroups automatically quoted the older material first, and therefore t h e i s s u e d i d n o t a r i s e. A larger, much older issue (sometimes mistakenly conflated) is to include past material for orientation, but e d i t i t d o w n.
A little more history, if you are interested, appeared 4 Jan 2006 in rec.food.cooking news: snipped-for-privacy@corp.supernews.com
currently Google-archived at
formatting link
I liken "top posting" to passive verb voice in written English. Some writers lean on it unconsciously (especially the academic and the illiterate ;-), others rail against it, just as mechanistically. As Mary-Claire van Leunen said in her _Handbook for Scholars,_ which many US scholars badly need to read by the way and which was, by happy coincidence, contempraneous with the invention of newsgroups (1979), passivity is a useful valuable tool but only if you understand it.
DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.