Attention Mr. Scarpitti.....

Nov 23, 2004 4 Replies



> I do know my Italian wines fairly well, and I find it most
> distressing that more people don't bother to learn more about
> the rest of the wine world than California Chardonnay or Cabernet S.

Do you recognise these words (yours!!!)


How dare you even suggest that "more people should learn more about *the rest of the wine world*" when you are so obsessed with the wines of I___y, that, by your own admission, you have no experience whatsoever outside of I___y.


Why don't you heed your own words?


You may actually find that, while I___y certainly does produce *some* excellent wines, by far the great volume is rather ordinary stuff, devoid of any special characteristics.


On another note, even more ridiculous is another of your "pearls of wisdom" that you developed this pathological hatred of France and can judge 60 million French people on the basis that you "once flew over France"


Migod, go get a job with the CIA. They need people with these skills - in Iraq!!!!!


Just remember, France *does* believe in State-sponsored terrorism - you may just have made it onto the DGSE's list of most-wanted.


Have a wonderful thanksgiving, enjoying your I_____n turkey!!!

Gross generalisation based on ignorance and stereotyping from a hysterical poster. "By far the great volume" of French wine could be labelled the same way.

P

The point is that I have to expend a lot of effort to learn about and find these Italian wines. They're not at the supermarket. I live in Ohio. Several local winesellers are very sharp, and Roger Gentile in particular is quite keen on Italian wines. He goes there regularly and visits the winieries. He knows many producers quite well. Often I will mention a wine from an article or book I have read, and he'll try to get it for me. That's how I got hold of the Valentini Trebbiano d'Abruzzo, the most wonderful white I have ever drunk (and I HAVE drunk a $50 Mersault). As a result, I admit that I know nothing about Californian or F_____ wines. But I know more about Italian wines than most people who drink wine.

Yes, it's easy just to go along with the crowd and drink the usual California suspects. I don't do that.

And you are complaining about how hard you work to find out about Italian wines in Ohio?

I live in Wyoming, and my preferences run to cool climate wines (French, German, Pacific Northwest, eastern US), although I really like Italian reds because they have good acidity. I can't say that I drink enough California wines to have developed favorites, but I think some of their Cabs are good. But generally, I have to drive to places like Washington State to sample the good stuff.

So go ahead and share your experiences with undiscovered Italians. I'm sure there are a lot of them, and this group would like to hear about them.

With better people skills, you could be the next Matt Kramer, extolling the virtues of undiscovered Italian gems.

Tom Schellberg

Get a copy of the Wines of Italy by David Gleave. It's very thorough. I have learned a lot from it!

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required