France-US co-operation

Recently I returned from a week and a half visiting Burgundy from the US (to learn more about the wines and especially thir recent vintages). In Burgundy and in Paris, talking to dozens of people about wine and food and other things, everyday things, I encountered persistent grace (and remarkable patience with my own limited French). I'm embarrassed to consider (for the Nth time) receptions awaiting a person with comparably limited English, visiting the US.

Going there on the 10-hour long-haul flight, my seat neighbor was an experienced French businessman with some years in the US. I asked him frankly, since I had not been in France lately, if I should expect to see anti-US prejudice. "Yes," he answered, "from stupid people." "As in the US, then," I replied. I did not encounter any such prejudice there (more the opposite, in the wine industry -- demonstrations of warmth and generosity toward people who had troubled to visit and learn from the wines and the winemakers' views). I did hear US pop music everywhere, and see Matt Damon ubiquitous on billboards for the latest US movie (no different from 1972 when the billboards in Paris showed a distinctive logo of a hand grasping marionette sticks and the title "Le Parrain," starring Marlon Brando; and the radio DJs blaring in open-air markets announced songs by "Nel Dee-a-mond").

(I forgot about stupid prejudices until reminded by a bit of atypical traffic on the wine newsgroup, which as always is what we make of it.)

-- Max Hauser (California)

Reply to
Max Hauser
Loading thread data ...

I have to agree with your observations. From the 10th of June until 18th of June this year I visited both the Alsace and Cotes Du Rhone regions and had no problem because I was an American. I speak no French but do speak a limited amount of German. The French citizens that I met had one interest in common and that was wine. I have visited France every year for the past ten years and will be there again in October and I am sure I will have a splended time once again enjoying the wine and people.

Reply to
sibeer

"Max Hauser" wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@corp.supernews.com:

In the wine and tourist industries you will also encounter people who share our (tourist) interests as well . The weak dollar which is good for many US Businesses and is hell for French winegrowers and US tourists.

Reply to
jcoulter

Salut/Hi Max Hauser,

le/on Sun, 26 Sep 2004 15:51:28 -0700, tu disais/you said:-

Well said, Max.

That's exactly what I find living here.

(:-)))

Reply to
Ian Hoare

Well...even I have to agree---prejudice is stupid...its not limited to anti-semetic, Black, Homo sexual....its prejudice anytime you generalize against a group of people.

I have made anti-France statements here and I don't agree with their Anti-Bush Sentiment....but I also do not agree with Bush. I buy French Wines and refuse to do the O'Reilly Boycott of French wines. I don't have to like French policy or USA policy...but food and wine and the producers of such do not necessarily support politics either.

I hope that my next trip to France...hopefully Spring 2005 will be excellent as well.

Glad your trip was good.

Regards,

Dick

Reply to
Richard Neidich

It's not just the French who have a distaste for Bush. He's the most unpopular US president (in terms of the rest of the world) for a long long time. And that includes most of his allies (read some non-US news services if you disbelieve me). Which will probably help to get him reelected, just to shove it to the French, or some other easily targetted political football (plus of course Kerry seems to have well and truly fizzled). I believe the world may well be worse off for that. But if someone attacks your leader, the natural reaction is to rally around them, even if they stink to high heaven. Very clever (and cynical) politically really to beat it up for all it is worth. Employ the siege mentality, it's ageless.

And anyone who listens to, and takes seriously, someone like O'Reilly (I assume you refer to Crazy Bill O'Reilly) I would suggest should broaden their horizons a little. And stop watching FOX. Far far right wing propagandists are responsible for many of the problems in the Christian world, just as they are in the Muslim world. Extremists of any variety, left, right, up, down, should all be kept well away from the gun cupboard.

And the only real reason I can decipher for attacking the French so viciously in the US is that Americans know where (or at least nearby) France is, can identify French ppl and their language, culture and produce. An easy political target, particuarly when you consider the US was the major partner in trade. Those fromage eating surrender monkies. How dare they not support a very dubious war after all we did for them in WWI and WWII.

The coalition of the willing part 2 consisted of three countries, one of which supplied a '74 Kingswood ute, Bazza, his dog Gyp and his .303 lee enfield. O and Shazza made the sandwiches. So why aren't ppl boycotting Italy for not being in on the act straight up? Or Russia? Or Germany (they had a Franco-Germanic love-in thanks to the US)? Or any other of the multitude of countries opposed to the initial war? All the countries that opposed it in the UN and other channels? And still do? Or the Spanish? The list is quite long.

It's all politics. That is why. The French are an easy scapegoat. So stop punishing the French. All you are really doing is propogating false predjudice against ppl, who for all their faults, are as innocent (or as guilty if you prefer) as most in this matter.

And judging by some of the blind hatred towards the French that pops up in this NG, the misled visciousness towards the French in the US is at a frenzy. Is drinking a bottle of burgundy really going to end western civilisation? It all seems rather silly to me, even considering the terrible terrible and tragic deep wounds the US have suffered in recent years.

Reply to
Mat

Salut/Hi Mat,

Although I agree with some of what you say, can I ask you very nicely please NOT to allow yourself to be tempted again.

le/on Mon, 27 Sep 2004 18:06:17 +1000, tu disais/you said:-

I don't think there's not much of that, Mat. A couple of twits who behave like three year olds exposing themselves to get a reaction, but that's about all. Some others can't resist dragging in a little anti-french (or anti-american) crack here or there, but in general we manage to remain above nationalistic politics.

My main reason for responding though is to ask you all not to continue this thread. This group is about friendship and bonhommie, and discussion of the (manifold on all sides) political shortcomings of one country or another is not going to help. This is especially true in the run-up to the Presidential election in the USA. Inevitably feelings will run high and we risk being polarised and divided, where we should be capable of agreeing to disagree.

Reply to
Ian Hoare

Max, I have had a similar experience as yours in my many visits to France. I was in France this year for almost three weeks in Champagne, Paris, and Provance and found no hostility or negativity towards me as an American. In fact the folks in Champagne are and have alway been so overwhelmingly warm that I continue to visit and make lasting freindships there. My conversational French is probably in the "C" to "C+" range ( I have difficulty in certain regions with the local accents especially in Burgundy) but we always seem to be able to converse and exchange ideas. At worst case I've had a few bummer cab drivers but I've had that in virtually every city in the USA! Bill from Ohio. Bi!!

Reply to
RV WRLee

Mat, its not really just a French thing. I am not sure if you hare here in USA or elsewhere but with the Bush-Kerry Presidential election there is not a group that is boycotting Heinz Catsup because of Theresa Heinz Kerry.

Its so rediculous as her husband was a republican that died and she inherited some stock that provides about $50 Million dollars of income a year from Heinz. But she has not real say in the way the company is run. She is not on the board of directors.

Heinz had to put press statements out---see their web site:

formatting link

It never ceases to amaze me that in a world where we stand for freedom...we chastise someone, punish them for having a different point of view. I think Ian said it best----people need to learn to agree to disagree and move on.

Thats what I have done and I have been buying the crap out of some fantastic French wines the past few years and my only bitch with the French is the really good wine cost to much and all the anti french sentiment does not lower the price so that I can buy more :-)

Reply to
Richard Neidich

Why should there be an anti-US feeling among the French? Most people know perfectly well that the American people cannot be blamed for what the US administration did, simply because the majority of the US citizens did not vote for Bush...

Yves

Reply to
yves tychon

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.