When this was first reported I posted this on another forum:
"I'm cynical enough that almost every time I read of a big theft the question of insurance fraud pops into my head. But in a super-wealthy community, it wouldn't be shocking that cherry picking thieves could get a very high average value from the stars of a big collection. As noted, at least one was a magnum (and I'd call $6000 low for value of '59 Petrus 1.5L). Throw in things like good vintages of La Tache/ Romanee Conti or Jayer's Cros Parantoux, '59 TBAs, etc, and it wouldn't be hard to average $3000 (even if some of the bottles were only worth $1500). "
It seems now they agree with me and have upped the value of the '59 Petrus. :) Still, it's funny that the other examples they use (mags of '59 Beychevelle and '02 Jones Family) are well under $1000 in value, so they need a few more really expensive bottles to reach a $3K average.