Re: air pumps?

Mar 11, 2005 3 Replies

Actually, the previous poster is limited in his experience and knowledge. Costs that are "far too much" is a very subjective statement.



Winekeeper and Enomatic, e.g., produce quality equipment that will reliably maintain the integrity of partial bottles for up to 3 weeks.



One of the 13 informal fallacies of elementary logic is "proving the general by the specific". The technology of nitrogen or argon displacement works indubitably. Partial vacuum systems do not.



Whether one can afford a hobby or not has nothing to do with the laws of physics.


>>
>>It does work, but not as well as the bottles of nitrogen spray that you
>>use to exclude oxygen from the bottle.
>
> One really nice aspect of the VacUvin-type device, however, is that you > can
> travel with it. On the road, a pump and a few stoppers will go quite a > ways
> toward keeping the wine "better" for a few days. I use these all of the > time,
> and, coupled with refrigerator storage of opened bottles of both white and
> red, I get about 3-5 days of useful life from a bottle. I will not claim > that
> the bottles (actually the wine IN those bottles) is as good as when first
> opened, but it will extend the life some. While I've got several nitrogen
> purge units, I have basically retired them, even the big unit, that cost > me
> far too much - but it does look impressive with the hoses, the cylinders, > etc.
>
> Hunt
>

I've seen two newspaper reports (SJ and Phoenix) on competiting storage methods, and both of them found VacUVine better that any of the gas systems. YMMV.

I have not tried the two systems that you mention, but I have opened a bottle, from the same case, after pouring from a 3-4 day old VacUvin'ed, refrigerated bottle and the differences are minimal. While I would not argue the vacuum method v inert gas replacement for long-term storage (as I have never done a controlled experiment between the two), for short-term, the vacuum method does the job. As to the relative expense of the two types of systems, I have them both, and, as stated, do not bother with nitrogen any longer. This may be because wine seldom sits around my house, but when it does, the vacuum/ refrigeration method does a fine job.

Hunt

"Brian Gordon" in news:d0r8hu$ck9$ snipped-for-privacy@reader1.panix.com...

Whatever is this, Brian? External data, basis for your assertions?

Aren't postings about technical devices for wine supposed to have only unsupported conclusions, proof-by-conviction? Surely the more firmly it's believed by its writer, the truer it must be.

Get with the program! ;-)

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required