Sea Smoke Pinot and a short rant

I'm sipping the 2002 Sea Smoke "Ten" at the moment. I bought a couple of bottles on futures, which was still $50+. The AVA is Santa Rita Hills, which has become quite the thing recently in Pinot circles - especially after the movie "Sideways".

This is a dense, rich, well balanced wine - even at 14.5% alcohol. There's plenty of new French oak present too, but not an excess. It's a very skilfully made wine - well polished, I'd say.

Too many new winemakers are putting stuff on the market that I would charitably describe as barrel samples. These wines are cloudy, under-oaked and immature to the point of still tasting grapey, and of course unfined and unfiltered. They aren't particularly shy about tacking a big price on them either.

One that comes to mind is a Melville (Santa Rita Hills) Pinot Noir I bought a year or two ago. They may grow great fruit, but I don't like their minimalist approach to winemaking.

Another winery that does this to some degree is Presidio. I really like some of the Pinots they have produced, but they throw a lot of very fine sediment in bottle that is extremely difficult to decant from efficiently.

I *hate* drinking cloudy wine! Suspended solids interfere with the flavor of good wine by mucking up the palate feel. IMNSHO, misguided winemakers who shun fining do a disservice both to their wines and their customers, and all it would take to address this issue effectively is a light bentonite fining prior to bottling.

Tom S

formatting link

Reply to
Tom S
Loading thread data ...

DrinksForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.