TN: Christmas Dinner

Dec 29, 2004 3 Replies

At a gathering at my house of my wife and kids, with my parents (visiting from the US), my cousin's family who also live here in Tokyo, and his parents and sister (also visiting from the US).


**1989 Philipponnat Champagne Grand Blanc - France, Champagne, Mereuil Sur Ay, Champagne

As an aperitif, with asian-seasoned avacado mash in endive leaves and ikura on toasts as finger food.



Deep golden color. Slight mousse suggesting a champagne with more age. Impression created by visual of mousse was carried through on nose and palate. Maderized mature champagne aromas and flavors that would have led me to think this was significantly older if tasted blind. Nose showed little to no fruit. Had a honeyed character, slight yeastiness, but a more primary yeastiness than a bread yeastiness. Palate was more interesting, but suffered from a lack of acid. Fruit was primarily quince and fig, with subtle bits of apple and lime. Enjoyable and, above all, interesting, but not very exciting or lively. Quality of storage not in question. And I do generally like mature champagnes.


**2002 Huët Vouvray Sec Le Mont - France, Loire Valley, Touraine, Vouvray

With a soup of pureed Japanese winter squash (kabocha) and pureed assorted Japanese mushrooms, moistened enough to allow the pureeing with a roasted onion stock. Enriched with a little cream and a little walnut oil smuggled in from France as a Christmas gift by a friend. Finished with crisp fried onion and garlic crumbs. More like a veg puree than a soup.



Very, very light straw yellow..crystal clear. Expressive nose of tart apple, stone fruits, mineral, and nutmeg. Great acidity on palate. I wanted to give this one time to develop, but it was hard to stay away from...one of those wines that makes you want to drink it right up. Called to mind Hugh Johnson's quote on claret -- "goes down like water". Light body and mouthfeel containing explosion of tart fruit, pebbly stones, honey without sweetness. Elegant like liquid velvet. Can you tell I like it?


**1989 Domaine Rabasse-Charavin Côtes du Rhône Cuvee Syrah - France, Rhône, Southern Rhône, Côtes du Rhône


From magnum.


With simple roast duck (cassis mustard and honey glaze), parsley crusted lamb rack, and various typical Christmas sides.


Mature (though not heavily faded) lighter red color. Not tending to orange, but all of the ink is definitely gone. Nose with the slightest bit of dust and leather and stable, but still clean. A little allspice and just a hint of pepper, but mostly subdued raspberry and dark cherry fruit. Other than fruit opening up a tad, very little evolution over the course of an hour. Palate shows barely noticeable fully resolved tannins, raspberry fruit, and just enough acid to hold it all together. A pleasure to drink with the duck and lamb. a good demonstration of the aging potential of a simpler wine with good balanced structure to start.


**2001 Mas de Boislauzon Côtes du Rhône Villages - France, Rhône, Southern Rhône, Côtes du Rhône Villages

Follow on bottle with the duck and lamb.



Young, deep dark red. Rich nose of sweet berry fruit, spice, anise, and herb. Round and smooth with mild tannins, little to no noticeable acid, and strong deep raspberry fruit with a light pepper spice and a tad of chocolate. Pleasantly full body and good finish in which the fruit lingers. One of the better CdR I've had recently. Makes me glad I bought a case for current drinking, though I wouldn't wait on this one.


**1988 Andre Beaufort Champagne Rose Grand Cru Doux - France, Champagne, Ambonnay, Champagne

Degorge -- May 2004



With a charlotte russe.



Light, clear strawberry color with lively mousse. Strawberry color notes carried through to strawberry fruit on the nose, accompanied by candied citrus and marinated cherry, with just a touch of cinnamon and even a little floral hint. Rich sweet mouthfeel that stood up well to charlotte russe. Surprisingly good acid balanced the sweetness. This wine just screams strawberries and sweet cream from front to back of mouth, though a little lemony touch keeps the finish from cloying. Generally not my style of wine, though it is the best match for the charlotte I've ever had.


**1989 Huët Vouvray Moelleux 1ère Trie Le Haut Lieu - France, Loire Valley, Touraine, Vouvray

With an array of cheeses.



Deep yellow-gold, crystal clear, solid to rim. Except for depth of gold, could have been a baby. Nose showed immediate honey richness, peach and apple fruit, ground stone. Developed apple pie type spice and fleeting citrus notes as it sat, as well as a yeasty sweet cheese character similar to brie baked in pastry. Mouthfeel that would have suggested TBA sweetness, but less sweet than that and balanced by an acidity that kept it as fresh as bubbling streamwater. Complete from front to back of palate, with still primary fruit and flavor like waxy honeycomb. Long, long finish with that pleasurable slight stinging in the back of the nose that comes from good lavendar honey. Great bottle of wine!


Jim



Jim,

thanks for notes (post more often!). Especially liked the Loire note. Have had both the 2002 Huet Le Mont sec and their '89 Haut Lieu 1er Trie Moelleux, what fantastic wines.

If I come to Tokyo in May, any interest in an "offline"? Dale

Dale Williams Drop "damnspam" to reply

Dale:

Thanks for the kind words and encouragement. Actually, one of my New Years resolutions is to get more organized about transcribing my tasting notes from my mind or the scrap of paper where they reside. Of course, this probably means I'll also be inflicting them on others more often.

I love those Huet wines. There are only a few things that I can come back to again and again just be stunned every time....great Loire chenin blanc, certain red and white Burgs, certain Barolos and Barbarescos, the occasional stunning Mosel. I love lots of other wines, but those are the ones that have the ability to knock me flat even though I think I know what's coming.

If you make it to Tokyo, I would love to do an offline. My other NY resolution is to try to get a semi-regular tasting group together over here. I've indentified a few suspects. Your visit would be a great excuse to get something put together...whether just a coupel of us or something more substantial.

Take care,

Jim

[] ] **1989 Domaine Rabasse-Charavin Côtes du Rhône Cuvee Syrah - France, ] Rhône, Southern Rhône, Côtes du Rhône ] ] From magnum. ] ] With simple roast duck (cassis mustard and honey glaze), parsley ] crusted lamb rack, and various typical Christmas sides. ] ] Mature (though not heavily faded) lighter red color. Not tending to ] orange, but all of the ink is definitely gone. Nose with the slightest ] bit of dust and leather and stable, but still clean. A little allspice ] and just a hint of pepper, but mostly subdued raspberry and dark cherry ] fruit. Other than fruit opening up a tad, very little evolution over ] the course of an hour. Palate shows barely noticeable fully resolved ] tannins, raspberry fruit, and just enough acid to hold it all together. ] A pleasure to drink with the duck and lamb. a good demonstration of the ] aging potential of a simpler wine with good balanced structure to ] start. ]

Courinne Couturier is a fine and reliable producer, certainly one of the best in Cairanne. One can always purchase her wines with confidence, and cellar them too. (I haven't run across this one, BTW, I thought the only pure syrah she made at that time was a Vin de Pays de Principaute d'Orange!) I still have a couple of bottles of '89 Estevenas hanging about... :)

Worth pointing out that not every CdR can go this kind of distance, but there are those that can, and it's really worth while IMHO to hold them for the duration!

[] ] ] **1989 Huët Vouvray Moelleux 1ère Trie Le Haut Lieu - France, Loire ] Valley, Touraine, Vouvray ] ][] ] the back of the nose that comes from good lavendar honey. Great bottle ] of wine! ] ]

A great from a truly fabulous vintage. Wish I had some, you've shaded me green! :) Glad this was enjoyed by someone who appreciates it.

-E

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required