Longrow 10 y.o. OB and Brora

Feb 27, 2004 7 Replies

Hi everyone,



This is a kind of follow-up on a previous thread titled "Bowmore 17 OB and Sig Ardmore 1992" where Longrow and Brora were highly recommended. There was some good discussion in that thread regarding both malts (Bart, blackkeno, and many details from Serge V.) with the consensus being that a malt drinker is definitely missing something great having not tried either of them.



Last night I tried my first Longrow, a 10 y.o. 1993 OB at 46%. I also tried a Brora (it was a Douglas Laing 50% single cask...I don't know what age/year this Brora was). The manager of the store has open bottles of many different malts, and let me sample both of these. He gave me a little water for the Brora, and asked me if there were any other malts I'd like to try. This is the first store where I've been offered the chance to sample the malt I was considering. Of course I'll be a return customer...it's a great little shop.



I ended up buying a bottle of the Longrow. Very peaty, very intense...I liked it very much. I haven't yet opened my bottle to get a better taste.



I found the Brora interesting, unlike any other malt that I've tried to date, and I was really having trouble identifying the tastes within it. I liked it, but I don't think I would spend the money to buy a bottle of the DL Brora. I guess now I'm wondering if I'd like an OB Brora better.



Side note and slightly off topic, but discussed in recent threads: Japanese single malts. I've been seeing a lot about Japanese single malts such as Suntory, but I can't find them anywhere! Even the store where I've been shopping (200+ malts!) doesn't have them and won't anytime soon. I'd love to try one...just out of curiousity.



Anyway, enjoy your malts, Sean


What store and where, please?

Thanks -- Larry

My reply is at the bottom:

Hi Larry,

The store is Federal Wine and Spirits and it's in Boston. Are you are familiar with Boston? The store is at 29 State St., right next to the old state house and diagonally across the street from Faneuil Hall. The store is tiny (I thought I was in the wrong store the first time I entered), but they have the malts lined up over and to the sides of the sales counter. I think they have more malts than just what's on display.

Sean

My reply is at the bottom. snipped>

Hi Serge,

Thanks for the link...there's quite a bit to look at there! That reminds me that Clynelish is another one I'd like to try. Is there a particular Clynelish you would recommend?

Thanks, Sean

Hi Larry,

The store is Federal Wine and Spirits and it's in Boston. Are you are familiar with Boston? The store is at 29 State St., right next to the old state house and diagonally across the street from Faneuil Hall. The store is tiny (I thought I was in the wrong store the first time I entered), but they have the malts lined up over and to the sides of the sales counter. I think they have more malts than just what's on display.

Sean

snipped - my reply is at the bottom

Hi Serge,

Thanks for the link...there's quite a bit to look at there! That reminds me that Clynelish is another one I'd like to try. Is there a particular Clynelish you would recommend?

Thanks, Sean

Hi Sean, all,

Well, as most Broras are single cask bottlings (except the two OB's and RM's and the G&M's), it's true that they gather various styles. I'd say there are:

- Around 1970 to around 1977: all quite heavily peated, either almost unsherried (like the two recent OB's, most Rare Malts, G&M's and most DL OMC's or Platinums) or very sherried (like a few DL OMC's, the Broraggeddon, the whiskyshop's bottling etc.)

- From around 1977 to 1983 (last year): some quite peated, like some DL OMC's, SigVin's or RM's, but most very lightly peated like Clynelish (most SigVin, Silver Seal, Chieftain's, G&M, DL OMC's etc.)

So, whatever the Brora you had, there are most certainly many other ones which are very different. What's sure, is that if you felt the Longrow was much peatier than the Brora, the latter was certainly distilled around

1980-1982. Very good, but far from being the best...

You can check

formatting link
if you want to dig a little deeper...

Santé

Serge

dans l'article fQy%b.47601$ snipped-for-privacy@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net, Sean à snipped-for-privacy@WhIsKeYatt.net a écrit le 26/02/04 19:29 :

Sean, you've made my day. Although I now live in SW Florida where the Single Malts are VERY expensive, I travel back to Boston often on business. The next time I'm there 29 State will be one of my first stops. Very much appreciate your information.

Dave

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required