French shelf meeting - don´t be shellfish, boysh ...

Aug 31, 2004 4 Replies

Hello;



The friendly neighbourhood eating and drinking society, a k a the French Shelf, met Saturday in our respective homes (consecutively). Theme: shellfish (and, I´ll tell you, that was one hard theme for us who did the dessert!). Monsieur Rutger served his wine blind - wrapped in alu foil. [C] Pale yellow, no fizz. [N] SLightly shy, due to low temperature, but evolved obvious slate and petroleum character (Hey, lot´s of kerosene in this one! as the host exclaimed). Possibly a bit floral. [P] Very exuberant, dried pineapples, petroleum, good and elegant acidity, lingering fruity RS, ends on an unexpected note of black currant leaves. OVerall impression: We were in total agreement that this was a Riesling, also, that it was not European (but made in a European style, somebody said) - not the light elegance of Mosel, neither the robust alcoholic bombs of Alsace. Self suggested Australia, which was voted down on grounds of most likely coming from a chillier clima. Xina pinpointed it as NZ, and it was: Stoneleigh 2002. SEK 94 (EU 10+). Good QPR. Possibly we´ll lay down 3 bottles and save for a few years to see what comes out of it.



Engels Brut Alsace Cremant THis was the entry of our neighbours the Garage Wine Importers. [C] Fairly pale. Mousse flighty. [N] First sniff cognacy oak, then turns to saffron and bees wax. [P] Rather fresh acidity, quite dry, light weight. Overall impression: Very good cremant that does not try to be anything else - no nods in a champagne-y direction. SEK 120 and I´ll have 6 bottles for New Year, thank you, Svend.



Xina had made a PAvlova (wrong: she made two pavlovas) and with this we served the next entry



[C] Medium gold [N] Fresh muscat aromas, elderberry blossom, tropical fruits [P] Sweet but not cloying, a bit of acidity to back it up, not obviously alcoholic. OVerall impression: THe gang was by now a bit organoleptically challenged, Svend recognised it for a fortified wine, but, sadly, no one recognised the varietal. Inf act, it was George Duboeuf Muscat beaume-de-Venise 2002. I tend to consider MBDV a bit uninteresting, without much personality, but this was rather good - not so cloyingly sweet as amny of them are.

The last one was served with coffee and dark chocolate and, really, no blame attaches for anyone for not recognising that: [C] Very dark purple red, close to black [N] Dark fruits, jammyness, perhaps cherry pits [P] Again, dark frutis, tannines, young and muscular, with good length Overall impression: This was, in fact, the sweet fortified wine from the great Bandol producer Tour du Bon. It is made from Grenache and Marc, and is called "d´ou?", which is a pune or play on words - as written it means "from where?", but pronounced, it sounds like "doux", i e, sweet. My guess is that this wine could sleep the sleep of the just in the cave for a few years and may possibly evovle - when we tasted the prototype at the producers back in



2001, it had as I remember a much more mineral nose. This was the 2000 vintage.

And the next theme, in November, will be game. Aaaaah.



Cheers!



Nils Gsutaf


Hi Nils, Although NZ is most renowned for its "in-your-face" Sauvignons, Riesling is a variety which is very much at home in this cooler maritime climate.

Most knowledgeable pundits say that NZ Riesling is as distinct in its own way as NZ Sauvignon - and should be very highly regarded.

Of course, it is not a "vogue" variety among consumers - and winemakers struggle to sell it - regardless of it quality.

And Stoneleigh has quite a track record in producing that slightly off-dry style - it will cellar very nicely thank you for another 5 or so years.

"Mark Lipton" skrev i meddelandet news:ch294b$cvd$ snipped-for-privacy@mozo.cc.purdue.edu...

Mmmm, not old, really, vintage of 2002, so, is ... (feverish calculation, ending in slightly blue smoke venting from self´s ears) a couple of years only. But I´d love to see it evolve, and perhaps a tasting with a few Germans, possibly a light Alsatian ... say in 2007, or 2008 ...

But Good Herr Doktor Professor, we DID. Don´t you remember an unlabelled bottle, produced under exhortations to complete silence (password is swordfish), a very dark fluidum ... sssh ... this is not supposed to be generally known ... and self remarking, This has a very mineral nose (I did, I swear I did, I had, in 2001, an opinion of a wine in front of Mark Lipton and Mike Tommasi) and you answered, yes, it´s funny how it sort of leaves/passes through teh fruit and becomes only mineral ... something of that kidney ...(the comment after the ellipsis was mine, not yours).

"st.helier" skrev i meddelandet news:noVYc.19932$ snipped-for-privacy@news.xtra.co.nz...

Well, that settles it - I´ll be off for the Systembolaget first thing ... Thursday, and buy meself a couple of bottles for cellaring purposes. And, I certainly agree - the lack of consumer interest in Riesling is perplexing. Will the tide of Chardonnay turn?

Cheers

Nils Gustaf

Oh ye of short memory!!!!!!!

Does't thou not remember trying to find the Southern Cross on a cloudy evening in Hawkes Bay with M. Hoare "yum-yum-yumming" away inside, following a glass of 1991 Villa Maria Reserve Noble Riesling!!

Nor, the Corbans Amberley Riesling of the same vintage, partaken of in Blenheim the evening before we dined at Hertzog?

Oh why did I bother!!!!! ;-)))

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required