OT: Laguna dining ripoff

Aug 04, 2004 92 Replies
Jump to replies (92)

Had a bad experience at a Laguna Beach restaurant, and I'm curious as to whether others find this as over-the-top as I do. We spent 10 days visiting various of Betsy's relatives in California (wedding at Tahoe, various cousins in Bay and Sacramento areas, and ending up in Laguna at her grandmother's for a few days). Will post tasting notes in next day or two.



In Laguna we mostly ate in, but we took the opportunity Friday night to have our one dinner for two. We'd visited some Laguna places like 5 Feet on previous visits, wanted someplace different. Someone on a website (Egullet, I think) had praised French 75 , a "bistro" in Laguna. Part of a group of restaurants by someone named David Wilhelm.



Betsy called Th. for a reservation, left a message asking for 7 PM. When we got back in, there was message saying we could have 6:30 inside or 7 on patio. She called back, left message saying 7 on patio was fine. We got another message, asking us to confirm time. She called back, spoke to a live person, confirmed



  1. We arrived at 7:04, gave name. Lady at desk asked if we were sure we had made reservation under that name. Yes, 3 times. Receptionist gives us a look, but seats us.

They bring winelist, but no menus. Menus appear (quite)a while later. Waiter recites specials. I order the shrimp appetizer and short ribs, Betsy a salad and a "surf and turf" (my words, not theirs)special. I order a half of 2001 Lafond Sancerre, and a half of 2000 Ch. Coutet (a St.Émilion, not the Barsac!). Nice bread with some kind of truffle mayo.



The wines arrive. Um, that's a 1999 St. Émilion. Well, ok, even if it's a lesser (cheaper) vintage, the 1999 might be more ready than most 2000s, right? I approve opening. First courses arrive, the shrimp aren't the tastiest I've had, but at least not overcooked, and in a quite good cognac/roasted tomato sauce. Betsy enjoys her salad (which includes nice manchego). I notice other tables have nicer Spiegelau/Riedel glasses, but I am not going to complain- I understand that they might reserve for people spending a bit more. As smoking people at next table leave, we're still hoping for a good night.



Main course arrive. My braised short ribs are tender, and sauce is good, though meat itself is a tad bland (maybe they could have braised it in that sauce?). Betsy's lobster tail is very good. But as she cuts into filet, she realizes waiter never asked how she wanted. Medium-well meat. She's unhappy, but says since she didn't specify medium-rare she doesn't feel she should send back.



Waiter brings dessert menu. I'm not a dessert person, Betsy says she could have dessert, or we could walk home via beach. I confess to having eyed a real deal on wine by the glass menu. 2000 Chateauneuf-du-Pape, Chateau de Beaucastel for $15.25. But Beaucastel for $15.25 seems unlikely, as mediocre vintage of Silver Oak is on list for $25. I ask waiter, "this is really Beaucastel, right, not Coudelet de Beaucastel?" "Yes, Beaucastel." "Really? Seems inexpensive" Some hemming and hawing, then "Well, it's Chateau de Beaucastel, not Beaucastel, it's the second-tier". That makes no sense, but rather than determine whether it's Coudelet, the Perrin negociant CdP,or what, I just ask for the check. When it comes, I gulp. The price for Betsy's small filet and lobster tail is $65!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Now, I guess we should have asked. But my assumption when waiter recites specials is that they are in the range of other main courses (which in this case went from $20 to $36). Now, with beef and lobster, I expected it to be a bit more- $40 maybe, and I wouldn't have been totally shocked at $48. But $65 for overcooked meat and a lobster tail? This is a "bistro" on Coast Highway- for the special and her $10 salad Betsy could order a tasting menu at some top NYC places! I started to ask for manager, but again, I hadn't asked price. We decided to try to salvage our night by walking on the beach. I tipped 15% of the pre-tax (inflated) total, instead of my usual 20+. I did circle the $65 and leave a note how ridiculous this was. Ended the night with a nice walk rather than a confrontation with manager.



Am I off-base feeling this is a total ripoff? Despite the reservation glitches, we went into dinner with high hopes. I wasn't upset by the vintage switch on the Bordeaux, that happens a lot (I do feel the listing for the CdP borders on fraud). But am I only one that feels that if a price is not given for a special, it should be "in tune" with the other specials, not almost twice as expensive as the most expensive thing on the menu. Curious as to others' reactions. I'm sure some will say I should have argued re price then and there, but I was trying to salvage our only night out alone. I'm betting that they feel they can get away with this because it's a resort town, and they're less dependent on repeat customers.



Dale



Dale Williams Drop "damnspam" to reply


in article snipped-for-privacy@mb-m05.aol.com, Dale Williams at snipped-for-privacy@aol.comdamnspam wrote on 8/4/04 12:28 PM:

Dale,

First..... We've lived in the area directly inland from Laguna for over 20 years and have been to French 75 several times, as well as to several of David Wilhelm's other restaurants. We have never had a bad meal or anything really egregious at any of them. French 75 has always been a totally pleasant experience. I certainly wouldn't call this anything even remotely near what I would have expected.

Second........ one would hope that any restaurant, certainly one of any significant caliber, would have properly trained staff and pay a high level of attention to details. Each of the specifics you encountered seems to me to be one in which a quality staff person would have handled things differently. If, somehow, the reservation was not properly taken, the hostess would be in a difficult situation, but should be skilled enough to handle it with no visible "attitude". The rest sounds like an inexperienced (maybe bordering on incompetent) waiter. He caused a situation that severely damaged the reputation of the restaurant. Admittedly, there were opportunities for you to have mitigated things, but that's really not the guests' responsibility.

I once took a party of four to a better (though chain) seafood place for an

8:30 PM dinner reservation on a Sunday. At 10PM the manager unceremoniously 'informed' us that they were closing and we would have to leave..... no apology whatsoever, no stacking of chairs on nearby tables to give us the hint, not sure what was said to the two other parties still finishing up nearby. Next day I called the corporate office of the company and asked for the CEO. A few days later the regional VP called me personally and was really very apologetic, advising that the manager had been spoken to and was in the process of being "re-trained".

I think David Wilhelm would like to know about your experience. You can find the company's address and phone on their site:

formatting link

Oh, and when he sends you the gift certificate for a free dinner.... please e-mail and I'll send you my address so you can pass it along. ;o)

Dale, Your question gets to the heart of an ethical dilemma I've often wondered about: are restaurants under any obligation to inform patrons about specials priced well above their normal offerings? I've also been shocked by the extravagant pricing of some off-menu specials. In some restaurants, they do announce the prices of all the specials, but I find that the "better" places seem to feel that it is declassé to do so -- and we as patrons adopt that view and resist explicitly asking about price. I've noticed in my travels in Europe that such a conundrum is usually avoided by the listing of specials and their prices on chalkboards or other written media, but again that practice is usually eschewed in the US by the "finer" dining establishments, except those whose menus change daily and so have no "specials" per se. To answer your question (bet you thought I'd forgotten, didncha?), I would have reacted almost exactly as you did, with internal shock mixed with outrage but feeling a bit helpless to do anything about it. Of course, I'd also think thrice about ever returning to such a place, but that's rather a moot point for you...

I hope that the rest of your trip was better! (and I expect *very* detailed descriptions of your Bay Area dining and wine experiences)

Mark Lipton

--snipped horror tale--

A few years ago, shortly after USAF retirement, I was working for a "major aerospace defense contractor" in the LA region. Went with wife on several restaurant excursions. Found that my experience with Michelin *** joints in Europe was no preparation for grand luxe dining in Southern CA.

First rule is that merely being there with ability to pay is not adequate for good service. You must be a "name" in LA. Great difference from places like Troisgras, Lameloise, Bocuse, Laserre, Girardet, et. al. If you aren't recognizable they are extending a privilege to an unworthy and they don't hesitate to let you know it.

Noteworthy and related was the stop at the Ritz-Carlton for an end-of-evening libation. SWMBO thought maybe an Armagnac. Menu for liquors revealed that Armagnacs available started at $160/drink and went skyward from there.

Bovine excrement. No one working for legal compensation pays those prices.

Ed Rasimus Fighter Pilot (USAF-Ret) "When Thunder Rolled" "Phantom Flights, Bangkok Nights" Both from Smithsonian Books

***
formatting link

in article snipped-for-privacy@mb-m05.aol.com, Dale Williams at snipped-for-privacy@aol.comdamnspam wrote on 8/4/04 12:28 PM:

I got so caught up in defending the restaurant itself and acknowledging your horrible waiter that I overlooked the price issue. No-price menu "Specials" are often a source of consternation for me as well. I admittedly find it distasteful to have to ask the price, but know I must be ready for just about anything if I don't. A part of me really resents being put in the position of having to ask or later feeling the pain of not asking. With the market price of fresh lobster being what it can be, a 'surf and turf' (assuming it was lobster and not shrimp) would be a 'red flag' item.

$65 would certainly be on the upper end of the pain scale for me. I don't know that I'd go so far as to call it a rip-off (especially since I know that French 75 is frequented by locals all year, so I doubt they're just taking advantage of tourists- maybe all of us :ol) but I'd have to agree that twice the average entree makes the best case I've heard for announcing the prices.

small

guess we

specials is

issue.

for me

price,

part

or

Personally I hate being told about a special without being told the price. I don't find it distasteful to ask the price at all. I find myself often asking the price even if I have no intention of ordering it.

[SNIP details] I think that Ed might be correct as to the geographic location of the restaurant and the attitude. I've encountered similar, even in other fine- dining cities around the globe. At some point, the star-centric attitude just takes over. Others have also stated that a good host/hostess would ask only once, and then seat you without ever missing a beat. I received the same response as you from a once grand restaurant, here in Phoenix. Though there were tables available and several waiters/servers/bussers standing by, we were grilled repeatedly about the reservations. I happened to hear the wife make them, and then called myself to confirm. I also overheard the telephone conversation, when they called back to re-confirm. We were asked to wait in the bar for about 30 minutes, until a "table could be prepared... " even though there were about twelve already set, from where I stood.
[SNIP again] A thought: unless I know the restaurant, and the chef du jour, I'll ask for a menu to facilitate my wine selection(s), along with a few minutes ( uninterrupted, I hope) to make my decision.
[SNIP] I thought that CA was a non-smoking state. Oh wait, did you take the patio seating? Even so, I guess I'm wrong about the smoking issue. Anyway, this is the point that I become the "glass snob," my wife's worst nightmare, out of all of the characters in my repertoire. I often do this when I see lessor glassware on my table, and we are only ordering "by-the-glass" selections. Usually, a gentle inquiry will produce suitable glasses, but occasionally, I have to point and say, "I'd like to be served using one of THOSE."

A side note: IMHO, a good restaurant should have either a broad by-the-glass selection, or a broad enough range of half-bottles to cover their menu. It's great to dine with 6, or 8 folk, and have several bottles of appropriate wine, but more than half of our dining is just the two of us. I'm too frugal to order 2 full bottles to cover our bases, and waste much of it. So far, San Francisco and NYC seem to be the only geographical areas that practice broad half-bottle selections, and I always inform the server of my pleasure, when I encounter one, plus tip a bit better (all other things being equal).

Tough call here. A good wait-person should know to ask and to not assume. He/ she is there to serve you and make your meal a positive experience. You probably did what I would have done, given the circumstances, but the restaurant is partially at fault here. Fortunately, most often when ordering beef, I've found that "medium-rare" is the house choice, though what that means is based squarely in that particular kitchen. Too bad they erred to the over-done.

Not in the same area as the substitution of vintage at dinner, but in the realm of "the wait staff should know" department. At your question, had I been attending your table, I would have retrieved the bottle (unless it is stored in one of those inert gas chillers, or something, which I would carefully look in, and write down the info on the label), to solve any problems. I've experienced several restaurants that very casually list one wine, then substitute another, in the by-the-glass selections, assuming that most of their diners will never know the difference. I don't know how common this practice is, but some don't even seem to care when caught. If the waiter doesn't know, then he/she needs to find out. You asked a very valid question and your additional purchase hinged directly on the information that you were given, or not given. It either cost them money, or left you feeling less than served.

Some restaurants will charge what they refer to as "market price" for lobster, abalone, and a few other dishes. In general terms, this seems to be whatever they feel the clientele will bear, and has little to do with the price they paid at market. Asking the price is a good practice, but one that I too often do not indulge in. Again, the waiter should have pointed out that this dish was a deviation in the normal pricing of the rest of their fare. This can be a bit touchy for the server, because they need to be informing, and not the least bit condescending, as in, "sir how can you order such an expensive dish and I don't recall ever seeing you in even one teeny tiny film?" I once did not ask for a price clarification on the sommelier's suggestion that we start our meal off with a split of _______ (insert restaurant's name here) Special Cuveé from Roederer Estate, when I had ordered two glasses of Taittinger at US$25/gls. When the bill came, I found that I had been charged US$250 for a split of domestic bubbly!!!!!!! It costs more than either of the other two bottles with dinner (we were not driving and it was a four hour dining experience). He should have stated that his Special Cuveé was priced about 10x more than the two glasses that I had ordered, and I should have asked! Too often the feeling is "if you have to ask the price, you cannot afford it... "

I feel that you are well within your bounds to pose those questions. It does not sound like this establishment feels that it must provide a 100% positive experience to all of its patrons. Unlike another, who responded, I do not know this establishment, or their management group. If I've dined at any other restaurants in their group I did so unknowingly. I would feel, just as you do, given the situation, if that dulls the pain. Peace of mind needs to be part of any fine dining establishment's core values, just like great food, properly stored and served wine, and a knowledgeable and attentive wait-staff.

Sorry for the long-winded response, your less than stellar dining experience and for the snippage.

Hunt

We ate one night with another couple at a restaurant called Paragon at the casino in CT. The menu prices were normal (filet for $36). The waiter described the specials and one was a steak that two of our party went for... Turns out the special was $80. We were shocked, but the manager came over and took them right off the bill. None of us had ever heard of Kobe steak before. After most of the people I told the story to knew what Kobe was, I felt bad about them taking it off the bill. As you suggested though, when something is that much more expensive than most of the regular entrees they really should mention the price.

inexpensive"

[SNIP my blathering and the OP] , I do not know

I checked the site that Midlife gave, and yes, I have eaten at Chimayo at the Beach. It was a business meeting and the food was passable. This is probably their most casual property, and the wine list (or lack of) showed it.

On that same trip, we had recommendations for a board dinner, and the concierge had made reservations at French 75 (my wife remembered the name). As fate would have it, we discovered that the Huntington Beach Hyatt Regency had a "chef's table" right behind their restaurant. Why their own concierge didn't recommend THAT is beyond me, especially since I stated that we wanted a complete, elegant dining experience for ten with a "killer" wine list. We changed reservations, and the chef, the staff, and the sommelier made that an evening to remember. Board members still compliment me on the choice of dining, the fun had, and the wines, which were chosen by the sommelier for each course (I took that night off). We added a couple of wine-courses, and it was excellent!!!! After your experience, I'm glad we made our little discovery. It also saved having limos down to Laguna Beach for all the diners.

Hunt

Good example. Again the wait-staff should have done their job. At Prince of Wales at the Del Coronado, Kobe beef was being served at $75/portion. Our waiter graciously noted this as he listed the "specials, "even though some of the other entres were in the $45-50 range. We were informed beforehand, and there were no surprises - it was worth every penny, but had no mention been made, I could have suffered a coronary, since we had six guests.

Hunt

Replying to all at once:

1) First of all, I made a mistake in original post. It was Sat night not Fri, and we had called Fri AM (and then Fri night and Sat noonish). 2) I will forward to website email, and alert Midlife if I get a comp. :) 3) I realize that market price of lobster flucuates, but let's be real. I am unsure if this was a spiny lobster or a Maine. If Maine, I'd say this was the tail of a maybe 1.25 lb. lobster. Which are pretty well available nationwide for $10-12 retail. 4) I'd say there's more than a single substandard employee here (I will say the waiter was reasonably attentive). Obviously management sets pricing, and the other waiter on the patio also did not give pricing on specials (tables are very close together, I heard his spiel to 2 other tables). And the Beaucastel error was in print. I checked a bottle of 2000 Coudoulet this morning, it's clearly marked Côtes du Rhône - it would be impossible to make an honest mistake here. And I believe the Perrins's negociant CdP is clearly marked as Perrin Les Sinards, not as Chateau de Beaucastel! I figured that if they were charging $9-10 for a glass of Pine Ridge Viognier/Chenin, $15 Beaucastel was unlikely! 5) Mark, I'll try to get notes out on rest of trip ASAP. As we were mostly visiting relatives (none geeks,and only one couple even real wine drinkers), not exactly a vinocentric visit. We did eat at Plumpjack's Squaw Valley restaurant (decent, good CA list), Bistro Jeanty in Yountville (very good), and a good neighborhood place in San Mateo (La Lanterna). A couple Napa stops, but best winery visit was Tablas Creek in Paso Robles. 6) Indeed I should have asked. But Betsy ordered. Ah well, live and learn. Dale

Dale Williams Drop "damnspam" to reply

One time, at a resaurant called "Nine" in Chicago (entree prices ranged from $15-$25), I ordered one of the unlisted *appetizers* (Rock Crab, which I never tried before that). I expected the fancy-looking mixed-drink I had while waiting for our table to be the shocker of the evening. Imagine my surprise when it turned out to be the Rock Crab appetizer for $50. I should have known to ask (the place did look a lot trendier than their prices dictated). Other than that, the evening was top notch. But it left a negative impression, and I've still never managed to go back (though I drive by the place at least once a month).

Yeah, that's what I thought too. Until I visited another Chicago restaurant called "Phoenix". This is my favorite Chinese restaurant inside the city itself. The manager recogizes us since we dine there regularly, and always comes over to say hello. I was looking for something a little more than average Chinese, so I asked "What's the best thing on the menu that you would recommend?" His reply, "The best thing is not on the menu, but I can have it prepared for you." *RED FLAG* He then goes on to describe the dish (ironically, crab). They're not gonna get me too. "How much," I ask? "$16.95." "Great, I'll take it." When they brought the crab, it was HUGE. "Wow, what a deal," I thought. "Now I can write off the Rock Crab incident and sleep nights again" (exagerated humor). But when the bill arrived, I saw what I was not expecting. The $16.95 was per pound and the crab was 3.5 pounds. I called the manager over to explain. He apologized for the misunderstanding, knocked it down to just under 3 pounds, and sends us over two glasses of the house Gewurztraminer *every time* we visit (not a bad wine with Chinese at all).

Kindest Regards, V

Restaurant Phoenix is our favorite spot for dim sum in Chicago, but we've never had dinner there (heard good things about it, though). It's nice to hear how well they handled what could have been a very ugly scene. It also sounds like you handled the situation with good grace.

Mark Lipton

Our favorite for Dim Sum, located not too far away, is a place called Happy Chef. Food is awesome, service is tolerable, although the atmosphere can be a bit irritating (right down to the disposable plastic table cloths). But you do get good bang for the buck, and I enjoy theirs more than I do Phoenix's. If you're looking for a tasty bite to eat on a Sunday afternoon, and you're in the area, be sure to check it out.

Salut/Hi Dale Williams,

le/on 04 Aug 2004 19:28:56 GMT, tu disais/you said:-

I can't speak as to CA or even USA restaurant practice. Judging by the comments from others, many of the things I find utterly unacceptable, seem to pass without comment.

  1. Reservation. I'm afraid that I'd be bristling after that "welcome". I might even decide that they wanted to have some kind of status game, and after saying that "yes, three times" added ,"how many times do your guests normally have to re-confirm before you believe it?" I've never EVER had my reservation queried, not even in the snootiest 3 star places in London. I arrive at the desk and say "I have a table booked for 8pm in the name of Hoare". "yes, Mr Hoare, your table is ready". ONCE, we had "I'm terribly sorry, Mr Hoare, the table is being laid up now, would you care to have an aperitif in the bar as our guest?"
  2. Menus. I want the food menu before or with the wine menu, how the heck can I decide on what to drink if I don't know what I'm going to eat? Actually, what I want, as soon as I'm settled (give me 2 mins max to settle at the table) is to be proffered the menu (both together for me as host, and one food menu each for the others) with the question "Would you care for a pre-prandial/aperitif, sir? Once we've ordered drinks, I want to be left alone for at least 10 mins (this isn't normal in the USA, and I accept that one may have to tell the waiter that "we're not quite decided yet, thanks") to chat over the menus.
3 Ordering. I expect a senior waiter to take the order, so that I can ask various questions, "are there any chef's specials? Are they available on the fixed price menu (which is what often happens here)?" And so on. In fact, a half way decent restaurant will print new menus every day, so there's no question of "chef's specials" not being priced. If there was such a beast as a special NOT being priced in any way, I don't really know what I'd do. I think it betrays a complete lack of professionalism - especially in these days of computers and word processors. I think the waiter SHOULD say, when asked "we have the $30 seafood lasagne the $65 surf and turf, the $20 home made venison sausage with lentils and the..... I don't think it's fair to put the client in the position of asking, in order to avoid a nasty surprise.
  1. Steak. Not even a half way professional place forgets to ask the client how they want the beef cooked. Ridiculous.
  2. Wines. In a place charging these prices, it is out of order for you not to be told of substitutions. I probably would have asked for the sommelier to come to my table, and upon being told there wasn't one, then (in a slightly aggrieved and louder voice) "well ask whoever it is that's responsible for the wines to honour us with his or her presence". Especially with that nonsense over the Beaucastel.

No!! At the least, you should say "wasn't it a 2000 on the menu?". It sounds very much to me as if you're getting the bum's rush.

Exactly.

try to salvage our

It's not JUST the price of the surf and turf, Dale, it's the whole damn business. I'd have called for the manager, and explained in words of one syllable that you have no problem with paying for the meal, but if you're being gouged, could they try to do it with more politeness, more competence and better grace. In view of the evident incompetence of the waiter, I'd either have tipped nothing, or an insulting 2%.

No. You're not.

For me it's not the price per se, it's the incompetence that would have got to me. At least the waiter didn't feel obliged to say "Hi, I'm Julian, I've here to look after you for the evening".

I sympathise with your wish not to spoil your only evening out, but I am afraid that for me, it would have been spoilt beyond remedy anyway, so I'd feel it my duty to let the manager know just exactly where they had fallen sort of acceptable.

You should certainly write to the owner, I feel. He can't _know_ surely, what's happening.

I find it strange that asking the customer how they want their meat cooked applies only to beef. I've never been asked how I wanted my lamb cooked, or pork or venison for that matter. Why is beef different?

I have been to places where someone ordering a steak is told "the chef cooks this medium-rare - is this OK?" Requests to have it done some other way are honoured, but with about the same grace as requests for salt and pepper. I rather like that, but then, I prefer my steak medium-rare.

Is this just a matter of opinion, of personal taste? Or is there good reason for "a point" being the standard degree of cookedness, as "al dente" is for pasta?

--brian

A good restaurant asks you how you want any meat, unless it is a predetermined 'doneness', as in baked, stewed etc.

I always order one grade less done than I want it in any place unfamiliar to me

- medium rare too often results in something without any detectable pink in the middle.

I will say that I once sent back two consecutive attempts at rare lamb and ended up eating nothing in disgust. They got zero tip that night from a table of 6.

IMHO Dale should not have tipped at all, given the level of service he received.

curious as

by the

unacceptable,

kind of

,"how

you

even in

say

Hoare,

Hoare, the

in the

how the

going to

mins

with

Once

mins

to tell

over

I can

print

specials" not

priced

a

when

the $20

think

to

the

I agree wholeheartedly with everything you say, with one slight reservation on this point. Certainly in the USA, everyone asks. But in some countries (Italy, for example; there may be others I'm not familiar with), nobody asks. In Italy it's assumed that you want it rare, and that's how they serve it unless the customer specifies otherwise.

ask the

meat

my

It isn't different--at least not always. I've often been asked that question about lamb, pork, venison, buffalo, tuna, etc.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required