TN: Panarroz 2005

Aug 18, 2007 5 Replies

Most of the time, I find myself in agreement with Hugh Johnson. The glaring exception being the highly touted Schramsberg sparklers, which are almost tasteless mouthfulls of Carbon Dioxide ad nauseum. But, I digress.



Last night, I uncorked my last remaining bottle of Panarroz Jumilla



2005 to accompany a pan broiled pork chop avec champignons and cubed pan fried russets plus asparagus. For some time, I have been puzzled by the designation of a name that translates to "Bread and Rice" alongside of a picture of a solitary Bird of Paradise blossom. Perhaps the connotation is that this wine conjures up an image of paradise when accompanying a wide range of food?

Johnson speaks of the Jumilla area of Spain as being in the mountains N of Murcia. "The Monastrell grape can yield dark and fragrant wines to rival those of Ribera Del Duero." "They can be fantastic when young and brambly, but don't last long in bottle."



I first discovered Panarroz perhaps a decade ago, and have found most vintages to have that seductive fruit, well balanced tannins, and lingering deep floral nose. Perhaps it needs food, and would not be so attractive when sipped solo. Come to think of it, the two items that were missing from last night's menu were "Bread" and "Rice." ;-)



Godzilla



Godzilla, are we shopping and buying wine at the same place? The last time you posted, I had just opened a bottle of the same thing. I, too buy this Panarroz Jumilla 2005 and like it enough to buy more.

I'm wondering if this redeems me from one (or was it more) of the posters here that said that I prefered Charles Shaw -- hence blah! blah! blah!

Dee Dee

Godzilla wrote in news:29290$46c6f767$cf9b1316$5584 @ALLTEL.NET:

I think Johnson is quite wrong in, at least, a couple of things. First, I do not think that they rival those of Ribera del Duero since they profile is very, very diferent (a good Ribera will be much elegant that a good Jumilla, which would be a bit more rustic).

And, second, it is wrong that Jumilla do not last long in bottle. That is surely true for lesser wines (from anyplace, not only Jumilla), but the great things really develop for the better over time.

My favorite Jumilla red is Julia Roch e Hijos "Casa Castillo" Pie Franco. And I have 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001 in the cellar. The 1998 was outstanding when just released and even better last year.

Best,

S.

My location and limited budget dictate that I buy most of my wine during forays into the big city which end with shopping at Costco. One can get a 10% discount on a mixed six bottles at HEB, but their prices are usually high enough so that it is still more expensive. IF one had pockets full of money and lived in a big city --- It doesn't cost anything to dream, does it? ;-)

Godzilla

This is what I have written down that I would drink again. Is this one that you might call a good Ribera, or only marginal? Ribera del Duero, Bodegas Gormaz, Soria Provence, 2005 Tempranillo, 90 pts. Jay Miller (whoever he is); Thanks, Dee Dee

"Dee Dee" wrote in news:fa7q8f$1mt$ snipped-for-privacy@registered.motzarella.org:

Dee Dee,

I am sorry that I have not tasted this Gormaz from the Soria province. 2005 was a great vintage for Ribera and all I have tasted from this vintage has proven to be quite good.

I have enjoyed Carmelo Rodero Roble 2005 and Prado Rey Roble 2005 and both are really good. As you know, it is probably too early for the Crianzas to show in the shelves, but the Robles come earlier because they do not have as much oak aging as the Crianzas.

I was very positively surprised by Prado Rey Roble 2005, specially because this was a winery that made awful things in past years but now showed a pure lovely fruit with no oak intrusion. REally good at the price.

Another wine, called Quintanal joven 2005, that sees some oak despite the name "joven" has been really nice and seems to be retailed in the U.S.A.

Best,

S.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required